your background makes it a "shoe in" for success or insanity-- which ever comes first. i too was an oil painter and still do a bit of sculpture. translating those talents to a small chunk of silver, gold, whatever, will test you. sometimes more than you may want. you're certainly welcome here...
hold up very well ? looks to me a few of the teeth have already met the fate you predicted ! i agree in part with john; the motif is kinda everywhere these days. i must also confess to having engraved a ton of nonssense for a lot of people. i guess one could call me a " gentleman of the night"...
for a spine that size the first leaves are way too large.leaving a glaring background. it's good that you see the pencil as a tool. get a book on scroll design and development.. lee grifffiths created a good one for beginners. the book starts you on the "right way" to do design work for...
welcome to the forum. if a rank beginner, not bad at all. rather good i'd say for push work. i see a few minor problems but i feel they will disappear without you even being aware of them. practice and time as many say, WIll bring perfection.
WOW!! it's been a very long time since you last visited here. welcome back. these pieces all show the excellent level of work you always did. i always enjoyed the bracelet work you shared
REGardless of the tool chosen, this is just something that must be practiced. practiced till it is automatic. you dont have to think about it, it just happens.
fabulous to my eye. really cool. i'v forged a few. engraved a couple and acid etched the rest. none were pipe hawks. you are blessed with a wife that appreciates such things !
best to avoid them in the first place. i think you should practice "popping out" just at the right time. this will eliminate the need for cleanup when finished. i've never done copperplate such as you show. not sure how i'd deal with the issue.
if they cut well without a problem, hmmm-- perhaps they're properly sharpened. sam is spot on. you must develop good sharpening technique to achieve consistently good ressuls.
the foto looks to be diamond drag from a pantograph. could be cnc. the foto isn't clear enough to tell. the surface could be dealt with if it's not too deep. if the ring is of low value, i'd simply buy another and start all over. the surface could be textured and otherwise be salvaged for some...
15 or 20, if any at all. thanks to sam, i I even tried rounding the bottom. best done if you have a sharpening system. by experimenting you'll likely find what works best in your hand for the particular type work you're doing.